Supplement Experts

Should I hire an estimate writer or a supplement company?

Picture of Max Rosenbloom

Max Rosenbloom

Nearly a decade of experience in the supplementing business, and an NRCA member. Owner of Supplement Experts.

Estimate Writer or Supplement Co Blog Image

Most roofers don’t start looking for supplement help because they’re curious. They start looking because something is already costing them time, money, or both.

Maybe the first scope came in too low. Maybe the adjuster left off obvious items. Maybe the estimating team is already buried in production, sales, and homeowner updates, and now there’s a stack of supplements sitting in a folder that nobody has time to chase.

From there, a decision needs to be made. Hire someone that can write estimates, or hire a supplement company and pay per estimate.

The Difference Contractors Need to Understand

A lot of contractors think they need someone to “write a supplement.”

But once they get into the process, they realize writing the estimate is only one piece of it. The real drag is everything that happens after that: submitting it correctly, answering questions, following up, documenting the file, and staying on top of the carrier until there is movement.

That is the difference between an estimate writer and a full-service roofing supplement company.

What an Estimate Writer Usually Does

An estimate writer usually reviews the original scope, adds missing line items where they can, and sends the updated estimate back to the contractor.

For some companies, that may be enough.

If they have an organized admin team, strong documentation, and someone who knows how to follow up with adjusters, estimate-only help can work.

But a lot of roofing companies need more than that.

When Contractors Need More Than a Rewrite

Many contractors don’t just need a better estimate.

They need a team that can step into their CRM, review the file, write the supplement, submit it, communicate with the carrier, and keep the contractor updated along the way.

They need the claim off their plate so they can stay focused on selling jobs, managing crews, and taking care of homeowners.

That is where Supplement Experts fits best.

How Supplement Experts Fits Into the Process

We are built for contractors who are tired of chasing every file themselves.

Our process is designed to work inside the systems contractors already use, like JobNimbus, AccuLynx, CompanyCam, and other CRMs.

When the documentation is there, we can review the claim, write the new estimate, upload it back for approval, and then help move the supplement forward from there.

Who Estimate-Only Help Works For

A company or contractor who only has a few claims a month and already has someone in-house who can manage the back-and-forth might be fine with an estimate writer.

Who Needs a Full-Service Supplement Partner

If you’re a bit higher volume and dealing with open claims, missed line items, adjuster delays, sales reps asking for updates, and homeowners waiting on answers, it’s probably time for a full-service supplement partner.

This is especially true when the supplement process starts pulling owners, sales managers, and production teams away from the work they should actually be focused on.

Questions Contractors Should Ask Before Hiring Help

The article should also cover the questions contractors should ask before hiring a roofing supplement company.

Do they only write the estimate, or do they also submit and follow up?

Do they work inside your CRM?

How fast is their turnaround when the file is complete?

Do they communicate with the carrier?

What happens once the updated RCV comes back?

These are the questions that separate a cheap estimate rewrite from a real supplement process.

Time for your business to enlist a supplement company?

We’d love to talk.

You can expect 20%-30% more on claims, less insurance work, and you only pay us when you get paid more.

Contact Us

*Note: Blog image generated with Google Gemini

Scroll to Top